Poorer households are worse off than we think

This seems like a good week to talk about the cost of living. On Tuesday, the UK Coalition Government put up VAT (sales tax) from 17.5% to 20%, which it somehow tried to spin as a ‘progressive’ move. This comes at the very time that petrol and food prices are rising – and this is without even starting to think about the numers of people whose incomes are declining due to unemployment or underemployment in the recession.

This all reminded me of the problems with looking at inequality through simple measures of income. Personally I prefer looking at expenditure inequality, because it more closely measures standard-of-living and avoids some of the problems with measuring inequality at the bottom of the income distribution – and it shows different trends in the UK, as the peerless Institute of Fiscal Studies have shown.

But both measures miss differences in the cost of living between rich and poor. Brian Landers over at opendemocracy has argued that lower earners inadvertently end up subsidising the rich through the pricing behaviour of supermarkets and car firms (h/t: Learning From Dogs). And more systematically, because richer and poorer people spend their money on different goods and services, they face different inflation rates, which are sometimes higher and sometimes lower.

While the IFS has – again – done some excellent work on this, the killer chart below comes from The Resolution Foundation, via Left Foot Forward. (We’ll be hearing much more from the Resolution Foundation; they’re a charity that focuses on low-to-middle income earners, who are now run by Gavin Kelly, the gifted ex-deputy chief of staff for Gordon Brown.  The graph itself comes from p68 of the Nov 2010 version of their exhaustive regular audit of the position of low-to-middle earners in the UK).

To interpret the graph, think of this as a cumulative inflation index from 2000 to the present day, comparing the different inflation on the goods typically bought by lower earners and higher earners.  Put simply, it shows that low-to-middle earners (‘LMEs’) pay £150/year more in 2010 than if they’d see the same average inflation since 2000 as higher earners. This has even come down in the past couple of years, down from a high of £300/year in early 2009.


My guess for early 2011? That we will see another jump in the cost-of-living for lower-income households, while mortgage-holders continue – at least for a little longer – to reap the benefits of low interest rates. Perhaps there are other, greater contributors to inequality happening this year in the UK, but we shouldn’t forget about the real impact of cost-of-living rises.

About Ben Baumberg Geiger

I am a Senior Lecturer in Sociology and Social Policy at the School of Social Policy, Sociology and Social Research (SSPSSR) at the University of Kent. I also helped set up the collaborative research blog Inequalities, where (after a long break) I am again blogging about inequality-related policy & research. I have a wide range of research interests, at the moment focusing on the role of social science, disability, inequality, deservingness, and the future of the benefits system, and I co-lead the Welfare at a (Social) Distance project (on the benefits system during Covid-19). You can find out more about me at http://www.benbgeiger.co.uk
This entry was posted in Blog posts and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Poorer households are worse off than we think

  1. Ben Baumberg says:

    I also just noticed another post by the Resolution Foundation at LFF, showing how median salaries in the UK fell by over 5% after taking into account average inflation. They do some really detailed analysis, and they’re very good at picking out the most important bits and blogging/writing about them – I’d definitely follow them in 2011.

  2. Pingback: Inequalities round-up: Jan 2011 | Inequalities

  3. Pingback: Who benefits from ‘economic growth?’ | Inequalities

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.